A Historical Trajectory: From Prohibition to Brooklyn
The origins of the Between the Sheets are as layered as the drink itself. The cocktail first surfaced in print within the pages of Frank Shay’s 1929 publication, Drawn from the Wood. In its infancy, the drink relied on a base of gin, Bacardi rum, and Cointreau. However, the recipe underwent a significant metamorphosis during its journey across the Atlantic. By 1930, iterations appearing in European bars had swapped the gin for Cognac and introduced a sharp acidic backbone of lemon juice, effectively pushing the drink into the sophisticated, citrus-forward category of the Sidecar.
The cocktail’s inclusion in the legendary 1930 Savoy Cocktail Book cemented its status in the canon of classic mixology. Yet, it arrived with a reputation for potency that has followed it for decades. Patrick Gavin Duffy, in his 1934 The Official Mixer’s Manual, issued a stern advisory to patrons, warning that the specific confluence of aged spirits could lead to “sudden intoxication” and “sick headaches.” This warning, while perhaps intended to manage the expectations of 1930s drinkers, serves today as a testament to the drink’s high-proof nature and its status as a potent apéritif.
The Evolution of the Recipe
Ryan Gannon’s relationship with the Between the Sheets spans two decades. His refinement of the recipe reflects the broader evolution of the craft cocktail movement, moving from the sweeter, syrup-heavy profiles of the early 2000s toward a drier, more ingredient-focused methodology. During his eight-year tenure at the acclaimed New Orleans bar Cure, Gannon placed the cocktail on the menu under a dedicated "Cocktails We Love" section, utilizing El Dorado 3-year rum and Pierre Ferrand Cognac to balance complexity with drinkability.
In his current role at Lonnie’s and Ingas Bar, Gannon has adapted the recipe to accommodate the constraints of a smaller, more efficient backbar. This necessity has driven a focus on "workhorse" ingredients—spirits that offer the versatility required to support both the classics and original house creations.
Technical Analysis: The Ingredients of Balance
The modern iteration of the Between the Sheets at Lonnie’s is a study in precision. Gannon’s selection of Frapin 1270 as the Cognac base is deliberate; it occupies the middle ground between the heavy, dark profiles of some industry-standard brands and the overly delicate expressions that might vanish when mixed with rum.
The choice of rum is perhaps the most critical component. Gannon emphasizes that the drink requires the "funkiness" inherent to older, traditional styles of rum. "If you don’t have that character, it’s not a rum and cognac drink," Gannon notes. "It’s just a Cognac drink that you’ve proofed up without actually adding any dimension." To achieve this, he employs Probitas, a blend that marries the robust, aromatic nature of pot-still Jamaican rum with the lighter, cleaner output of Barbados-based Coffey stills.
The final piece of the puzzle is the orange liqueur. Having moved away from traditional triple secs and the "candied" notes of brands like Combier, Gannon has opted for Flor de Azar. This Mexican product is an agave-based spirit infused with a complex botanical profile, including pomelo, mandarin, lime, orange blossom, tuberose, black pepper, and cardamom. When paired with Regans’ Orange Bitters—which also features a pronounced cardamom undertone—the result is a drink that feels familiar yet entirely modern.
Implications for the Modern Bar Program
The success of the Between the Sheets at Lonnie’s suggests a broader trend in the cocktail industry: the "retro-renaissance." As bars move away from the overly complex, multi-ingredient "tiki-adjacent" trends of the last decade, there is a renewed interest in three- or four-ingredient classics that prioritize quality of spirit over spectacle.
From an operational perspective, the drink’s popularity as an occasional special provides a template for how bars can manage inventory efficiently. By choosing spirits that perform multiple roles, Gannon has managed to keep his backbar streamlined without sacrificing the quality of the guest experience. For the consumer, the drink offers a bridge between the past and the present. Gannon frequently describes the beverage to curious guests as a "tropical Sidecar," or more whimsically, "the baby of a Daiquiri and a Sidecar."
Comparative Data and Market Context
The revival of such spirits-forward classics aligns with recent shifts in consumer spending. Data from the Distilled Spirits Council of the United States (DISCUS) has indicated that while volume growth in spirits remains competitive, the premiumization of the Cognac and aged rum categories continues to drive revenue in the on-premise sector. The Between the Sheets, which sits at a higher price point than a standard beer or wine pour, serves as a high-margin opportunity for bars looking to capitalize on the premiumization trend.
Furthermore, the drink’s status as an apéritif is particularly salient in the current market. As urban dining experiences shift toward "all-day" or "early-evening" dining, cocktails that stimulate the appetite rather than overwhelm it are seeing increased demand. By presenting the Between the Sheets as a sophisticated, pre-meal stimulant, Lonnie’s is successfully navigating the changing habits of the modern diner.
The Lasting Legacy of the Cocktail
The endurance of the Between the Sheets is not merely a matter of nostalgia; it is a reflection of the inherent balance of its proportions. The "sour" family of cocktails—spirit, citrus, and sweetener—has remained the gold standard for a reason. By stripping away the extraneous and focusing on the interplay between the funky, vegetal notes of high-quality rum and the refined, fruity structure of Cognac, Gannon has modernized a classic without stripping it of its identity.
Looking forward, the success of this specific cocktail at Lonnie’s serves as a case study for other operators. It highlights that the most effective way to engage today’s sophisticated drinker is not through increasingly obscure ingredients, but through the thoughtful re-examination of the classics. By providing context—telling the story of the 1934 manual and the 1929 publication—Gannon adds an educational layer to the consumption experience. This storytelling aspect, combined with the technical rigor of the build, ensures that the drink remains a staple of the menu, rather than a mere historical curiosity.
As the cocktail continues to be a hit with guests, it serves as a reminder that even in an age of rapid innovation, the foundation of a great bar program remains rooted in the history of the glass. Whether it is the "sudden intoxication" warned of by Duffy or simply the refreshing, sharp finish of a well-made sour, the Between the Sheets has successfully crossed the threshold from a forgotten relic to a modern classic.
Related posts:
